Refuse a new console question while cards from the send just collected are still open and unsettled

AI Assisted
This commit is contained in:
jparkerweb committed 2026-11-10 12:46:19 -08:00
1 parent 7f32c351b1
commit d1aab9d006
4 files changed
+68 -1

No files matched your search

+1 -1
View File
@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ test("settle: true records the send wait handed over, never a later one still un
assert.equal((await s.send("/submit", EXPORT_A)).status, 200);
assert.equal(waitFor(s).status, 0);
assert.deepEqual(readState(s.session).collected.ids, ["q1"], "collecting records which cards the send carried");
postPatch(s, { items: [choice("q2")] });
postPatch(s, { settle: true, items: [choice("q2")] });
assert.equal((await s.send("/submit", { actions: [{ i: "q2", type: "answer", kind: "choice", k: "B" }], reply: "Question q2: B" })).status, 200);
postPatch(s, { settle: true });
const items = readState(s.session).items;
+25
View File
@@ -1380,6 +1380,31 @@ test("rejects more than three open required questions", () => {
assert.match(res.stderr, /open at once/);
});
// The Dead Code run left the first two questions open after they were
// answered, because the next post never settled them, and the page landed on
// the old card. A post that asks something new now has to deal with them.
test("refuses a new question while the cards just collected stay open and unsettled", () => {
const sent = { at: "2026-11-10T10:00:00.000Z", kind: "choice", k: "A" };
const base = {
collected: { at: sent.at, ids: ["q1"] },
items: [{ id: "q1", kind: "choice", title: "Where to look", body: "b", status: "open", required: true, options: [], thread: [], submitted: sent }],
};
const ask = { id: "q2", kind: "text", title: "What next", body: "b" };
assert.throws(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [ask] }), /item "q1" settle: .*settle/);
const settled = applyPatch(base, { settle: true, items: [ask] });
assert.equal(settled.items.find((i) => i.id === "q1").status, "answered", "settle: true closes the card just answered");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { settle: ["q1"], items: [ask] }));
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ id: "q1", stands: true }, ask] }), "stands keeps a card open on purpose");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ id: "q1", _delete: true }, ask] }), "a deleted card is dealt with");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ id: "q1", body: "reworded" }, ask] }), "a reworded card is a new question");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ id: "q1", status: "reopened", body: "asked again" }, ask] }), "a reopened card is asked again");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ id: "q1", answer: { k: "A" } }, ask] }), "the agent's own answer settles the card");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch({ ...base, collected: { at: sent.at, ids: ["q9"] } }, { items: [ask] }), "an id that is no longer on the page holds nothing up");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ ...ask, required: false }] }), "an optional card asks nothing new");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { items: [{ id: "n1", kind: "notice", title: "Heads up", body: "b" }] }), "a notice asks nothing");
assert.doesNotThrow(() => applyPatch(base, { finish: { headline: "Done", body: "b" }, items: [ask] }), "a finish is not held to it");
});
test("rejects internal vocabulary in a title", () => {
const p = { items: [{ id: "j1", kind: "text", title: "Frontier grill posture", body: "b", required: false }] };
const res = cli(["post", "--session", sid, "--file", payload("jargon.json", p)], { expectFail: true });
+1
View File
@@ -89,6 +89,7 @@ After the person's note on an open question, reword it (same `id`), retire it wi
- a doc `version` that goes back (leave `version` out)
- a finish `command` with `<` or `>` in it
- a note left without a reply
- a new open required question while a card from the send you just collected is still open (add `"settle":true`, or reword, reopen, delete or `"stands":true` it)
- a `finish` while `stopWarning` is set or a helper is still `running`
- a `stop` with no `finish` (`stop --session <sid> --force` for a dead page)
+41
View File
@@ -639,6 +639,7 @@ export function applyPatch(state, patch) {
delete next.finish;
}
refuseQuestionPastNote(state, next);
refuseQuestionPastAnswers(state, next, patch);
return stampTimes(state, settleAgent(next, patch, state));
}
@@ -677,6 +678,46 @@ function refuseQuestionPastNote(before, next) {
);
}
/**
* The cards the person just sent (`state.collected.ids`, written when `wait`
* handed the send over) are the agent's to settle. A patch that asks a new
* question while one of them is still open, untouched and unsettled, leaves
* two cards in front of the person, and the page can land on the old, already
* answered one (seen in the Dead Code skill: the first and second questions
* stayed in the list after they were answered). So the patch that adds a new
* open required question must also settle each of them (`settle: true`),
* reword it, reopen it, delete it or say it `stands`. A finish ends the
* session and the dashboard draws no cards, so neither is held to it.
*/
function refuseQuestionPastAnswers(before, next, patch) {
if (next.finish != null || next.workflow === "dashboard" || !Array.isArray(next.items)) return;
const ids = Array.isArray(before.collected?.ids) ? before.collected.ids : [];
if (!ids.length) return;
const had = new Set((Array.isArray(before.items) ? before.items : []).map((i) => i && i.id));
const asksNew = next.items.some(
(i) => isPlainObject(i) && !had.has(i.id) && i.required !== false && i.kind !== "notice" && isOpen(i),
);
if (!asksNew) return;
// `stands` keeps a card open on purpose; an `answer` in the patch is the agent settling it with its own reading (see settleItems).
const dealt = new Set((patch.items || []).filter((e) => isPlainObject(e) && (e.stands === true || "answer" in e)).map((e) => e.id));
const left = next.items.filter(
(i) => isPlainObject(i) && ids.includes(i.id) && i.kind !== "notice" && isOpen(i) && isPlainObject(i.submitted) && !dealt.has(i.id),
);
if (!left.length) return;
throw new Error(
left
.map((i) =>
rule(
`item "${i.id}"`,
"settle",
'was answered in the send you just collected and is still open: settle it in the same patch that adds a new question, with "settle": true (or a list of ids), or reword it, reopen it ("status": "reopened"), delete it ("_delete": true) or send "stands": true',
{ settle: true },
),
)
.join("\n"),
);
}
// The person had the last word in a card's thread: their note waits for a reply.
function lastWordIsTheirs(item) {
const thread = Array.isArray(item.thread) ? item.thread : [];